I am loving the varying responses to this list, and where everyone seems to be in agreement. :)

I think I've grokked the essence of Supernatural enough that I probably don't need to watch it, but I will definitely keep your recs in mind. Sames goes for Parks & Rec. The others definitely need to bump up to the top of my list.

X-Files! Oh, I loved that show so hard. I used to get together with a roomful of friends to watch the later episodes; I miss that camaraderie.

However, as gorgeous as people have presented Hannibal to be, it is far too gore-geous for me to watch, alas.